This is Paradise | Place as state of mind
The Cameron Public House and 1980’s Toronto
John Abrams, Stephen Andrews, Isaac Applebaum, Rebecca Baird, Napoleon Brousseau, Brian Burnett, Derek Caines, Pauline Choi, Barbara Cole, Cathy Daley, Tom Dean, Reid Diamond, Lynn Donoghue, Andy Fabo, Elinor Rose Galbraith & John Scott, Eldon Garnet, General Idea, Oliver Girling, Sybil Goldstein, Matt Harley, Hummers (Deanne Taylor, Janet Burke, Jennifer Dean, Alan Bridle),Tim Jocelyn, Rae Johnson, Donna Lypchuk, Peter MacCallum, Tanya Mars, HP Marti, Michael Merrill, Handsome Ned (Robin Masyk), Andrew James Paterson & Alan Fox, Evan Penny, Randy & Berenicci, John Scott, Joanne Tod, Renée Van Halm, Video Cabaret (Deanne Taylor & Michael Hollingsworth), Julie Voyce, Lorne Wagman, George Whiteside, Tony Wilson
Curated by Rae Johnson and Herb Tookey.
Organized by the Museum of Contemporary Canadian Art
There’s a moment, some afternoons, when the sunlight filtering in from the street fills the Cameron’s front room with a soft paradisical light, and the wretched appear at peace. ‘This is paradise’, I thought, and when I finally left I had a sign-painter print those words, in gold, on the walls, by way of payment for my room.
Excerpt from the essay This is Paradise 1987, by Tom Dean
Introduction and Acknowledgements
The curatorial premise for the exhibition is to present a selection of work as cultural artifacts reflecting the early years of the Queen West art and music phenomenon of the 1980s.
This exhibition is dedicated to the artists and musicians and my theatre family who have supported the vision for this exhibition and Paradise Now, which recognizes and reclaims part of our story and part of our history in Toronto during an era marked by triumph and tragedy.
Artists in the exhibition who we miss dearly – Tim Jocelyn, David Buchan, Tony Wilson, Handsome Ned (Robyn Masyk), Reid Diamond, Felix Partz born Ronald Gabe, Jorge Zontal born Slobodan Saia-Levyborn, Lynn Donoghue, Tony Wilson, Clarke Rogers and, Paul Sannella (1946 – 2010), co-owner Cameron Hotel from 1981.
This is Paradise | Place as state of mind
The Cameron Public House and 1980’s Toronto
Upon opening its doors under the new ownership in October 1981, the Cameron became a magnet for the most talented and ambitious in the ‘hood. It came together as a kind of social experiment in the form of a hotel, similar to hotels like the Chelsea in New York, but fundamentally different in that it’s reason d’etre from the beginning wasn’t to sell beer and collect rent, but to provide a place for Culture.
As the “rag” trade receded from the area, large industrial spaces became vacant and the inevitable happened; the artists moved in and dominated the cultural ecology of the neighbourhood until the last years of the eighties, when AIDS and heroin shook the community and gentrification tipped the delicate balance.
1981. Painters Gordon Rayner, Gershon Iskowitz, Graham Coughtry, Robert Markle and Gwartzmans Art Supplies were already long time residents of the Spadina and College area. Almost overnight the Queen West and Spadina neighbourhood became dominated by artists of all stripes – dressed in the Queen West signature black leather. “We have more black leather than Queen Street West”, declared an ad on a streetcar shelter. The boundaries of this new art territory could be roughly mapped out as a string of bars starting at College and Spadina with the Silver Dollar where clientele could see naked performance artists at work. Down the street the El Mocambo, Grossman’s Tavern to King Street and the Spadina Hotel”s “Cabana Room”. Include Kensintgon Market and Fort Goof. Westward to the Horseshoe, the Cameron, to the Holiday Tavern at Bathurst and Queen and South again to King and Bathurst, the Wheat Sheaf.
There were many bars and clubs programming cutting edge music at the time, but the Cameron was the first andarguably the only one to see the possibilities of inviting all cultural and social manifestations of the moment into its edifice. During its first years, siblings Ann Marie and Paul Sannella, and their friend Herb Tookey, took hold of the visual art programming – a term which sounds too formal in the context of the era. Art was everywhere – on the exterior walls, the front and back rooms, bathrooms, hallways, ceilings. Interesting new musicians and singers were given a venue where they could develop their craft. The Cameron hosted a non-stop stream of fundraising events for the newly formed neighbourhood arts collectives. Given this melting pot environment, it is not surprising a long list of Canadian cultural icons can be linked to the Cameron. The close proximity of everyone, the availability of a public venue to perform or show work and the necessity of collaboration, brought to fruition ambitious projects like Chromaliving 83, involving over 150 artists representing every conceivable kind of cultural production. The Cameron was the nerve centre, where Chromazone kept its office.
A typical Scenario at the Cameron would have looked something like this: Molly Johnson singing her first Billie Holiday tunes on “Blue Monday”; Molly Johnson as chambermaid and resident: Handsome Ned singing “Put the Blame on Me” spine chilling; the Parachute Club raising the roof; Mohjah who brought Reggae directly from the Islands; loud ‘art’ bands; and ART.
Jenny Holzer’s lists upstairs as décor; I Brain Eater’s painted piano; Napoleon Brousseau ants on the sides of the building; the exterior murals; Sybil Goldstein’s baroque punk ceiling; constantly changing art on the walls; poetry readings; Video Cabaret’s Hummer Sisters running for mayor with their campaign slogan Art vs Art, (coming in second to Mayor Art Eggelton). Actors, writers and directors from Theatre Passe Muraille down the street, meeting and drinking; artists drinking after openings at the new galleries – YYZ, Chromazone, Mercer Union, A.C.T., A Space, ARC. The hot and famous – Billy Idol and his entourage dropping in after hours to hang out.
The old guys from the Second World War who still came to drink draft every afternoon. Rosedale art connoisseurs looking for art with their newspaper reviews tucked under their arms.
The first visual art commissioned by the Cameron received good reviews and brought it to the attention of the press and the arts community. In the back room were my paintings, commissioned by Herb for the Cameron. In the front room Eldon Garnet’s Privacy Show. On opening night Carmen Lamanna sat with Joseph Kosuth both wearing dark Italian suits, smoking cigars under my Halloween paintings in the back room, bringing the world of high art definitively to the Cameron.
1987. The project which probably best underlines the result of this cultural blending was a play titled Tragedy of Manners, commissioned by TPM artistic director, Clarke Rogers. The author was writer and art critic, Donna Lypchuk, best known for her long running column Necrophile in Eye Weekly, who really rattled the cage when she based characters in her play on actual people in the art scene including herself. The setting: Halloween night at the Paradise Hotel (the Cameron Public House). The cast: 42 characters, played by mostly non- actors who were known personalities in their own right, piled on even more irony.
Tragedy of Manners was a Queen West family affair. As Sheila Gostick famously proclaimed “Where there’s culture there’s bacteria.” The cast, designers and crew were actually the “people in your neighbourhood”, our neighbourhood Queen Street West. Actor Graham Greene built the set with Stephan Droege, and on stage Richard Minichiello, Runt, Maryn Cadell, Robert Stewart, Mark Harman, Whitfield Slip, Robert Nasmith, Paul Sannella, Edward Mowbray, and thirty-three more.
Looking back now there was a prescience about this play. Amid its grandiosity and ambition real tragedy was lurking. The characters personified death and decay and the corruption of body and spirit.
Love is unrequited, and gossip and pettiness rule. There is no redemption, only purgatory waiting for Hell. In the space of a year, Ned died accidently of an overdose, and many were becoming addicted to heroin. AIDS cruelly took the gracious and remarkable Tim Jocelyn from us. And many of our friends were becoming ill. As the mythology of Queen West grew, so did the rents. Artists began migrating farther West, some even left town or just disappeared.
Clarke Rogers hired me to design the set. True to the script, I created a surreal version of the actual Cameron including within it Tom Dean’s hand painted THIS IS PARADISE on the walls of the bar, but in reverse because the audience was in fact looking into a mirror at themselves. Art imitating Art imitating Life imitating Art. Donna Lypchuk’s ironic and scathing dissection of the Queen Street West art scene could not have been possible unless the halcyon days of Queen West and the Cameron were suddenly, over.
- Rae Johnson Toronto, June 2011